The idea that israel is an apartheid state is a staple of the boycott, divestment and sanctions movement, which has made the south african comparison practically the lingua franca of anti israel. The israel prison service revealed that an average of 204 palestinian children have been held in custody every month since 2012. A similar policy is seen in israel, where jewish settlements are established within. Some commentators extend the analogy to include treatment of arab citizens of israel, describing their citizenship status as secondclass. Why israel supported south africas apartheid regime. Peace not apartheid is a new york times best seller book written by jimmy carter, 39th president of the united states and laureate of the 2002 nobel peace prize.
Carter book stirs furor with its view of israelis apartheid. Confronting israels apartheid accusers a journalist who witnessed segregation in south africa seeks to show israel has little in. People, organisations and entire countries profited from machinery that was created in defence of apartheid. It is clear from this finely crafted collection of essays that israel has much in common with whiteruled south africa. On 24 may 1948, nine days after israel s declaration of independence, the south african government of jan smuts, a. Three key points that make this story especially juicy. The lie of apartheid and other true stories from southern africa it is one of the many bitter ironies about south africa that the policy of apartheid to which afrikaners clung for decades as their only hope and salvation from third world dominationwas in fact an impracticable and unworkable system which led. In this book carter argues that israels continued control and construction of settlements have been the primary obstacles. A new united nations report accuses israel of having established an apartheid regime that oppresses and dominates the palestinian people as a whole the publication comes amid renewed debate. It is an unfair and inaccurate slander against israel, calculated to retard rather. Early israeli relations with apartheid south africa. While israel s adversaries have always charged the country with many misdeeds, only relatively recently have these alleged transgressions coalesced into the socalled bds movement boycott, divestment and sanctions, modeled after the campaign against apartheid south africa, and based on the allegation that israel too is an apartheid state. The relationship was strongly centred around the arms trade.
The new book the unspoken alliance, about a secret deal between israel and south africa, has created controversy around the world but has largely been ignored by the u. He castigates rhetoric about a twostate solution or demands that palestinians should compromise, as if the solution could bypass the dissolution of israeli apartheid. Peace not apartheid is a new york times best seller book written by jimmy carter, 39th president of the united states 19771981 and laureate of the 2002 nobel peace prize. During his presidency, carter hosted talks between menachem begin of israel and anwar sadat of egypt that led to the egypt israel peace treaty. Brothers in arms israel s secret pact with pretoria this article is more than 14 years old during the second world war the future south african prime minister john vorster was interned as a nazi. The caller refers to author james bamfords book a pretext for. But his goal palestine peace not apartheid is a most worthy goal.
This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. When israel was apartheids open ally by lenni brenner jimmy carters book, palestine peace not apartheid, has opened up much of the american public to serious discussion of israel s realities. Israel and the apartheid analogy is criticism of israel charging that israel has practiced a system akin to apartheid against arabs and palestinians in its occupation of the west bank. There are numerous post across the web where mandella is quoted as calling israel an apartheid state just like south africa under white rule. Apartheid state secrets revealed in explosive new book. I was delighted to have mr tutu endorse my book israeli apartheid. The measure revealed that israel was prepared to violate yet another fundamental right to fall in love and marry the person of one. Israel an apartheid state download ebook pdf, epub.
Jimmy carters apartheid book partners for progressive. He responds to a caller who asks questions concerning pressure put on the us political system and the resulting support of israel. A concise introduction to israeli apartheid regime, but after a while you just get used to barbaric level of violence. An apartheid state zed books, 1987, uri davis provides a critical insight into how it was possible for jewish people, the victims of nazi genocide in the second world war, to subject the palestinian people, beginning with the 194849 war, to such criminal policies as mass deportation, population transfers and. In september 1979, israel, assisted by then apartheid. It reveals what mainstream media in the west seeks to conceal from the public. Israel s secret relationship with apartheid south africa, historian and foreign affairs editor sasha polakowsuransky explores the rise and fall of the cold warera alliance between israel and apartheid south africa. Apartheid south africa versus apartheid israel middle. The reports chief author is richard falk, a former u. Peace not apartheid broke a taboo, in many ways it added to the confusion surrounding discussions of israel.
Brothers in arms israels secret pact with pretoria. This smart and informative book should be read by every person who. This was revealed in the book apartheid guns and money. Carter makes it clear to me although surely not to all that hes not an enemy of israel, but he is an overly onesided critic. In this video, he explains why the comparison of israel to an apartheid state is false. Israel s repression of palestinian citizens, african refugees and palestinians in the occupied west bank and gaza has become more brutal over time. The unholy alliance between israel and south africas. As a jewish south african anti apartheid activist i look with horror on the farright shift in israel ahead of this months elections, and the. The secret arms deal between israel and apartheid south africa. In september 1979, israel, assisted by then apartheid south africa, illegally detonated a nuclear bomb in the indian ocean. See more ideas about apartheid, party rules and racial groups. Black leaders and the black press, for the most part, were jubilant, kelley writes in his book apartheid israel. Peace not apartheid, is devoted to circumstances and events in palestine and not in israel, where democracy prevails. A beginners guide also provides an easytoread summary of the palestinian nakba, or catastrophe, on which the creation of the jewish state was based.
Jimmy carter was interviewed on the pbs newshour broadcast of nov. But what we do know based on the above articles and sasha polakowsuranskis recent book is more about the symbiotic relationship formed between israel and the former south african apartheid regime. Miko peled was born in jersusalem into a famous and influential israeli zionist family. Opinion why israel is nothing like apartheid south africa. Palestine israel peace or apartheid download ebook pdf. Jimmy johnson the electronic intifada 2 august 2010. Isolated, and possibly due to its nuclear requirements, israel was cornered into seeking relations with south africa. Polakowsuransky demonstrates that the relationship was a strategic.
Despite israeli denials, evidence of radiation from what became known as the vela incident has come to light in australia 39 years later. The analogy has been asserted by critics of israel including scholars. In this book, white writes, the truth of israel s past and present is laid bare. Marc lamont hill has secured his place in the proud black. Opinion israel and the apartheid slander the new york. A beginners guide stresses that there is no point in trying to undo things that cannot be undone. Thats a problem and its not a problem about the book. A revealing account of how israels booming arms industry and apartheid south africas international isolation led to a. Benjamin pogrund, who spent 26 years as a journalist in south africa.
Danny ayalon is the founder of the truth about israel, former deputy foreign minister of israel, and former ambassador of israel to the united states. For example, he admits to being provocative in using the noxious term, apartheid, in the title of his new book, but he immediately explains that hes not referring to israel within. Brothers in arms israels secret pact with pretoria this article is more than 14 years old during the second world war the future south african prime minister john vorster was interned as a nazi. When israel does occupy this territory deep within the west bank, and connects the 200orso settlements with each other, with a road, and then prohibits the palestinians from using that road, or in many cases even crossing the road, this perpetrates even worse instances of apartness, or apartheid, than we witnessed even in south africa. In pondering a different kind of future, author ben white in his new book israeli apartheid. Palestinian boys are seen outside artist banksys newly opened walled off hotel in. Is israel apartheid reporting the facts on israel and. The historic truth, however, is that israel never willingly supported the apartheid regime, and is far from being the villain in this complex saga.
Click download or read online button to get palestine israel peace or apartheid book now. In the early 1970s, israel was in dire economic straits as a result of the yom. Israel however denies it is an apartheid state despite hundreds of apartheid laws in its statute book. Even more, it insults the real victims of apartheid in south africa. The israeli who tried to broker the deal was none other than shimon peres, who at that time was the israeli defense minister and is currently the. The idea of evoking the term apartheid to describe israel s treatment of palestinians was not invented by israel s critics, but by israel itself.
Indeed, the different faces of apartheid provides abundant evidence that israel is worse than south africa was, and that israeli apartheid will be more enduring than the south african variant. However i have to say that this book is just merely an introduction to the conflict and to fully grasp the an excellent book detailing the apartheid that. While apartheid can have broader meaning, its use is meant to evoke the situation in pre1994 south africa. Sasha polakowsuransky reveals the previously classified details of countless arms deals conducted. Israel is the only country in the world that systematically prosecutes children in military courts between 500 and 700 each year.
As a jewish south african antiapartheid activist i look with horror on the farright shift in israel ahead of this months elections, and the impact in the palestinian territories and worldwide. Secret papers have recently been declassified that prove israel offered to sell nuclear weapons to apartheid era south africa. Israel fears the apartheid label as it reveals its gruesome tactics. This smart and informative book should be read by every person who cares about israel and its victims.
1217 981 43 1476 271 1025 1518 875 408 296 395 423 265 135 619 1060 568 316 1162 1359 1203 4 729 533 203 1020 1217 239 289 829 87 351 172 1476 1019 1190 1511 187 458 750 837 703 135 36 1125 1348 906